Let’s get a few things straight…
29.6 million people voted in the General Election. That’s approximately 65% of the electorate.
Of those 29.6 million, 10.5 million voted for the Conservatives. That’s 35% of those who voted.
Under our First Past the Post system, which disproportionately awards seats for share of the vote, the Conservatives still do not have a majority of seats and therefore cannot immediately form a government.
This means that there is currently no alternative to the incumbent government. If Gordon Brown were to ask permission from the Queen to quit, she’d refuse: as yet, there is no alternative government.
So Brown is not “Squatting” in Downing Street as the squalid Murdoch Press alleges.
Under our system, there were no winners. It’s up to the parties now to take the mandates they have been given and represent them as best they can by arguing over the implementation of policy in a new government, making a deal and getting on with running the country. This process is now underway:

Clegg, true to his word, has offered the party with the most votes a first crack at forming a government. That party is the Conservative party. With a coalition, their combined votes would equate to about 58% of those 29 million and 363 seats.
However, if the talks finally fail, then under our current system, the Labour party has every right to try to form a government with the Liberal Democrats.
Of the 29.6 million who voted, 15 million voted for Labour or the Liberal Democrats. That’s 51% and 315 seats – still not enough to form a government, but possible still with assistance from other small parties.
If this situation were to arise, this new coalition would still be comprised of parties and MPs that people had voted for. Under our First Past the Post system, all parties are currently playing the game fairly.
The British people have had a chance to elect the Conservatives with a workable majority and have decided not to. We’ll have our next say in 4 to 5 years. That’s the system. If we don’t like it, we can change it.
The only party to have consistently offered this is the Liberal Democrats. The party to have most consistently opposed it is the Conservatives. It’s telling that once Brown offered to step aside yesterday afternoon, the Conservatives were more amenable to agreeing to a referendum on voting reform. They’re desperate for power and will make promises to get it.
Will they keep those promises?
As for this nonsensical whining about our “unelected Prime Minister”, that’s for another post.
Thank you thank you THANK YOU. All the Tory commentators talking about the other parties being "decisively rejected" by the country should take a look at the number of votes their party actually polled before they take the psephological moral high ground (as it were).
Oh so right sir! Here here and pip pip!
So well put Ciaran
I agree that politics abhors a vacuum and that GB is not Squatting. He is right to stay in post until a viable alternative government can be formed. This is the responsible and constitutionally correct thing to do. I have a bugbear about the press and the way it misrepresents and spins all news. News should be told in an entirely flat matter of fact way and if people find it boring and unsensational and turn off then that's their problem. However…If you take the view that we need a government at all then it needs to be able to govern. In a parliamentary system that means winning votes in the commons on it's legislative programme. In order, therefore, to not be a ship without a rudder someone has to win the argument for decisions to be made, whether it is on an individual vote in the commons or at a general election. All parties have their own interests at heart, including the liberal democrats, and whatever ones political views it is difficult to be properly rational and non-partisan. Peoples view of the LDs is that they are less partisan than the "old" parties and more reasonable and rational. I think this to be naive. All ideologies, always fail to take one factor into account. It is the most important factor of all, and it is Human nature. People will always try to improve their own lot, lie, cheat, steal, and stab people in the back to get to the top. Communism works perfectly on paper, but it fails to cope with human behaviour corrupting it to the ends of a few. ALL of the parties are desperate for power (it is this principle, incidentally, which is the reason for me being a constitutional monarchist – namely the monarch has been bred and nurtured for it from birth and doesn't have to lie and cheat her way to the top). My point is that none of the parties is holier than thou and that any semblance of noble thought or action goes completely out of the window when they need to fight for their survival. This means we don't get the representation we deserve. It means they are less likely to tell the truth. They will always be entirely unable to cooperate in a sensible and reasoned way. There will always be a hidden agenda. I don't believe this is what people want when they say they want a fairer voting system with less yah-boo politics. Thus if you accept that ALL (with a few notable exceptions on all sides) politicians are philanderers then we need to design a system that understands human behaviour and adjusts for it. A system where there is no incentive to be ignoble. What this is I have not yet decided but I don't believe PR is better than the current system but worse when you factor in human nature. I do believe the current system is unfair, primarily because the constituency boundaries are wrong. They are moved by the party in power to bias themselves (human nature again). They were last adjusted by Tony Blair to massively bias towards Labour. Surely it would be fairer if they were of equal size in terms of population. This would mean all votes were equal. I understand that LD voters are evenly distributed throughout the country whereas there are pockets of conservatism and socialism which leads to fewer LD politicians being elected. However, at a local level this means that if you are in village X and the majority of that village votes for politician Y then Y gets to represent that village. If voter Z in village X voted for a different politician he must accept that in village X he is outvoted. This leads to a representative of different corners of the UK having a vote on a particular school closure in their constituency etc. A problem with AV is that it is a case of everyone is equal but some are more equal than others. In marginal constituencies some people will effectively get a second vote whilst others in that same constituency do not!Finally, I would like to say I do not like tribal politics. I believe the whip should be made illegal in politics. Each politician should be allowed to vote according to his or her conscience and to reflect the will of their respective constituencies. Thus each piece of legislation will be voted on its own merits. This goes for voters too. I hate when people say I really don't want the conservatives to get in, look what Thatcher did to the country. What has Thatcher got to do with anything. She retired 20 years ago. The vast majority of politicians are different people now. We must be able to look at each candidate according to how they personally perform, what there individual views are and trust they mean what they say. We should judge people by what they say and do and not on what others have done in the past and not on where they come from or what school they went to. How is that Fair? I personally think Cameron is more honest than Brown or Clegg, based on the way I have seen him talk over the last few years. I think he is earnestly trying to sort things out for the good of the UK as a whole (and there is bound to be winners and losers in that) and that he can be trusted to be fair minded, to lie less than anyone in Labour has done over the last 13 years and be less perfidious than Clegg is appearing to be at the moment. Let us give him a chance and if I am wrong then kick him out. At least we know Labours poor record – Quod erat demonstrandum. We do not know Camerons yet. But I am willing to vote for hope over fear.
Also: A conservative/liberal coalition may provide the best of both worlds. The worst worries of Left leaning voters are unlikely to be realised from a Conservative government held in check by the Liberals. Surely a coalition representing the views of 59% of the electorate is more democratic than one representing 51%?
Jake – very well put. However, if you favour a Tory government, the best thing that could happen would be a Lib/Lab pact – it would be electoral suicide for both parties as Reid and Blunkett have quickly realised.The point that no one picks up on is that whilst only approx 35/40% of those that voted (65% of the electorate) vote for the party that forms the government, the UK government only has sovereignty over approx 25% of UK law. The rest derives from the EU whose principal law maker is the Commission, a body that nobody of any political view has voted for. Whilst the European Parliament is directly elected it does not initiate the vast bulk of EU legislation and it has no powers of repeal. In short you have no opportunity to change the government in Brussels. Additionally, the European Court of Justice makes a huge amount of caselaw that directly affects our lives and is not democratically accountable to anyone. If you want to seriously to increase democracy and democratic accountability in our country then you must take a long hard look at the EU. It is undemocratic and unaccountable and shows utter contempt for the will of the electorate as its attitude to recent referendums across Europe has shown.The Lib Dems are our most EU enthusiastic party which rather undermines their democratic credentials.
@ciaran: ejit,
@ciaran: ejit,
@ciaran: ejit,
Care to elaborate?
On what?
On what?
On what?
Can I point out that thats precisely 35% MORE than were able to vote for putting Brown, Darling and Mandy in charge for the last three years.
Excellent point, Labour are the undemocratic party of the millenium, the promise was to put blair in charge until an election was due. Also Brown was not elected leader of the labour party as he was the only one to stand and any opposition was crushed like little ants.
Excellent point, Labour are the undemocratic party of the millenium, the promise was to put blair in charge until an election was due. Also Brown was not elected leader of the labour party as he was the only one to stand and any opposition was crushed like little ants.
Excellent point, Labour are the undemocratic party of the millenium, the promise was to put blair in charge until an election was due. Also Brown was not elected leader of the labour party as he was the only one to stand and any opposition was crushed like little ants.
To be honest, I have had trouble differentiating between Gordon Brown and Robert Mugabe at times… other than having better spin (its not printing your own money, its "quantative easing")His "I'll step down…. in september" quip made me wonder for a second – is his idea of electoral reform "Prime minster for life" ?